Ellen DeGeneres made me cry

[Grimmy]

I agree to a point - an American Idol judge? Not so good! But she won't be back next season, so it is a moot point.

I actually kind of liked her as a judge! Much better than seeing Paula in her intoxicated stupors clamoring on about nothing and everything! So, who is in the line up for the new judges? I understand Randy is the only stand-out from the ol crew...

Grimmy

[lvdkeyes]

Ellen is a good comic, but has no background in music and it showed on the show. Paula is another story altogether.